
The Dance of Life
Havelock Ellis

THE CLASSIC COLLECTION · 1898
"Affirmations" by Havelock Ellis is a collection of literary-critical essays written in the late 19th century. It uses writers and saints as occasions for probing the “literature of life,” testing moral ideas and cultural assumptions rather than judging art for art’s sake. The pieces engage the most questionable aspects of conduct and belief to state a few enduring “affirmations,” while pressing readers to form their own. The opening of the work presents a preface and a long study of Nietzsche. Ellis contrasts a pure art-literature that raises no ethical questions with a literature close to life where morality must be examined, and he announces his intent to offer personal affirmations against the era’s self-congratulation. He then traces Nietzsche’s career—ancestry and austere youth, Pforta training, early devotion to Schopenhauer and Wagner, rise as a philologist, The Birth of Tragedy, the Bayreuth crisis and break with Wagner amid worsening health, the freethinking aphoristic middle period, the later “immoralist” doctrines, and the final mental collapse. Along the way he distils Nietzsche’s key ideas: Dionysian affirmation, the attack on Christianity and pity, conscience as tradition, the call to hardness and self-mastery, and the contrast between “slave” and “master” moralities, set against sharp national judgments and admiration for French clarity. He closes this opening section by valuing the middle Nietzsche most, proposing the dancer as his guiding image, and treating philosophy as personal psychology rather than a universal system.
Introduction adapted from the source catalogue; source summaries may be automatically generated.
Free to read · English · 61,622 words · No account needed
MAKE TIME FOR A GOOD BOOK
On by default. Untick to stop anonymous reading totals. Each page counts after 10 seconds in view. How this works.
Anonymous counting is on unless you have switched it off.
The first question is a large one, and, in Zola’s case at all events, it cannot, I think, be answered on purely æsthetic grounds; the second may be answered without difficulty. Zola has himself answered it; he admits that he has been carried away by his enthusiasm, and perhaps, also, by his extraordinary memory for recently-acquired facts (a memory like a sponge, as he has put it, quickly swollen and quickly emptied); he has sown details across his page with too profuse a hand. It is the same kind of error as Whitman made, impelled by the same kind of enthusiasm. Zola expends immense trouble to get his facts; he has told how he ransacked the theologians to obtain body and colour for La Faute de l’Abbé Mouret, perhaps the best of his earlier books. But he certainly spent no more preliminary labour on it than Flaubert spent on Madame Bovary, very far less than Flaubert spent on the study of Carthage for Salammbô. But the results are different; the one artist gets his effects by profusion and multiplicity of touches, the other by the deliberate self-restraint with which he selects and emphasises solely the salient and significant touches. The latter method seems to strike more swiftly and deeply the ends of art. Three strokes with the brush of Frans Hals are worth a thousand of Denner’s. Rich and minute detail may impress us, but it irritates and wearies in the end. If a man takes his two children on to his knees, it matters little whether he places Lénore on his right knee and Henri on his left, or the other way about; the man himself may fail to know or to realise, and the more intense his feelings the less likely is he to know. When we are living deeply, the facts of our external life do not present themselves to us in elaborate detail; a very few points are--as it has been termed--focal in consciousness, while the rest are marginal in subconsciousness. A few things stand out vividly at each moment of life; the rest are dim. The supreme artist is shown by the insight and boldness with which he seizes and illuminates these bright points at each stage, leaving the marginal elements in due subordination. Dramatists so unlike as Ford and Ibsen, novelists so unlike as Flaubert and Tolstoi, yet alike impress us by the simple vividness of their artistic effects. The methods adopted by Zola render such effects extremely difficult of attainment. Perhaps the best proof of Zola’s remarkable art is the skill with which he has neutralised the evil results of his ponderous method. In his most characteristic novels, as L’Assommoir, Nana, Germinal, his efforts to attain salient perspective in the mass of trivial or technical things--to build a single elaborate effect out of manifold details--are often admirably conducted. Take, for instance, the Voreux, the coal-pit which may almost be said to be the hero of Germinal rather than any of the persons in the book. The details are not interesting, but they are carefully elaborated, and the Voreux is finally symbolised as a stupendous idol, sated with human blood, crouching in its mysterious sanctuary. Whenever Zola wishes to bring the Voreux before us, this formula is repeated. And it is the same, in a slighter degree, with the other material personalities of the book. Sometimes, in the case of a crowd, this formula is simply a cry. It is so with the Parisian mob who yell “A Berlin!” in the highly-wrought conclusion to Nana; it is so with the crowd of strikers in Germinal who shout for bread. It is more than the tricky repetition of a word or a gesture, overdone by Dickens and others; it is the artful manipulation of a carefully-elaborated, significant phrase. Zola seems to have been the first who has, deliberately and systematically, introduced this sort of leit-motiv into literature, as a method of summarising a complex mass of details, and bringing the total impression of them before the reader. In this way he contrives to minimise the defects of his method, and to render his complex detail focal. He sometimes attains poignantly simple effects by the mere repetition of a leit-motiv at the right moment. And he is able at times, also, to throw aside his detailed method altogether, and to reach effects of tragic intensity. The mutilation of Maigrat’s corpse is a scene which can scarcely have been described in a novel before. Given the subject, Zola’s treatment of it has the strength, brevity, and certainty of touch which only belong to great masters of art. That Zola is a great master of his art, L’Assommoir and Germinal--which, so far as I have read Zola, seem his two finest works--are enough to prove. Such works are related to the ordinary novel much as Wagner’s music-dramas are related to the ordinary Italian opera. Wagner reaches a loftier height of art than Zola; he had a more complete grasp of all the elements he took in hand to unite. Zola has not seen with sufficient clearness the point of view of science, and the limits of its capacity for harmonising with fiction; nor has he with perfect sureness of vision always realised the ends of art. He has left far too much of the scaffolding standing amid his huge literary structures; there is too much mere brute fact which has not been wrought into art. But, if Zola is not among the world’s greatest artists, I do not think we can finally deny that he is a great artist.
Your reading position is saved on this browser. Take it to another device with a library code. Reading pages adapt to text, rather than matching a printed edition.

Havelock Ellis

Havelock Ellis
Havelock Ellis

Havelock Ellis
BEHIND THE BOOK
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using this eBook. Read the source licence.
The original source file, including credits and licence, is retained by this library. Request an original-format copy at no charge. Please include the book title and Project Gutenberg identifier #76076.
KEEP YOUR CURIOSITY GOING

David Patterson (Spirit) Hatch

David Patterson (Spirit) Hatch

David Patterson (Spirit) Hatch
Coulson Kernahan

Ralph Waldo Emerson

Maurice Baring